Dog Behaviorists - Page 13

Pedigree Database

Premium classified

This is a placeholder text
Group text

Premium classified

This is a placeholder text
Group text

Premium classified

This is a placeholder text
Group text

Premium classified

This is a placeholder text
Group text

momosgarage

by momosgarage on 23 January 2014 - 17:01

If you want to substantiate "certified animal behaviorist", try googling it and you may also find universities that offer it as a program of study.

"Certified Animal Behaviorist" is not the same thing as, "Board Certified Animal Behaviorist", nor is it that same thing as "Degree holder in the field/discipline of Animal Behavior", nor is it the same thing as "Certificate in Animal Behavior"

rtdmmcintyre

by rtdmmcintyre on 23 January 2014 - 17:01

Love your illustrations.  But I would like to say as being a general contractor.  Electrical Engineers don't necessarly know all the answers.  The difference is they know where to look to get the answer.

Mindhunt

by Mindhunt on 23 January 2014 - 18:01

E-Collars, that is one of the things my trainer/behaviorist friend hates because almost all the aggression cases she works with that are not the result of abuse is from e-collars.  She says there is a difference between inflicting pain/punishment and a correction which if done correctly is not producing pain.  She also said during training, you should never set your dog up for failure.  If you train properly, your dog wants to listen to you and please you, but there are still times when a dog is a dog is a dog and you try to prepare for those moments.  As for e-collars, there have been moments when I really wanted to use one Angry Smile lol

Mindhunt

by Mindhunt on 23 January 2014 - 18:01

Momo, there is a huge difference between PhD psychologists and PsyD psychologists and no similarity between either of those and a psychiatrist who is not there for therapy but more med pushing.  Also psychologists get hardly any reimbursement from insurance companies because insurance companies use a medical model which is counter to clinical psychology.  But that is for another thread lol....Wink Smile

As for trainers and training programs, I have a friend who went to one of those 9 month long "shake and bake" dog traing courses and learned everything from basic obedience to advanced protection where she can supposedly train a law enforcement K9.  Her "hands on" training was at the local vet office and animal rescue without supervision.  But she has that piece of paper that states she is certified.  She runs the local SAR team and believes dogs do not have to potty off the track and it is perfectly ok to let her dog (or any other dog) break tracking to mark on anything upright.  This was what she was taught.  I was taught dogs potty in the cold zone before entering the hot zone to begin tracking and never potty (unless it has been a very long track with water given) or heaven forbid mark on the track.   

I do agree it takes years of practice/learning and working with other knowledgable people to learn dog behavior and training. 

 

momosgarage

by momosgarage on 23 January 2014 - 19:01

Momo, there is a huge difference between PhD psychologists and PsyD psychologists and no similarity between either of those and a psychiatrist who is not there for therapy but more med pushing.  Also psychologists get hardly any reimbursement from insurance companies because insurance companies use a medical model which is counter to clinical psychology.
 


That wasn't my point, I am aware of the differences, my point was that many MD's and PsyD's have PhD's too, so the PhD does not signify a lack of knowledge, as stated by gsdstudent.  There are also many licensed MFT's and LCSW's with PhD's, even though they only need a masters to practice legally.  It also depends on the insurance someone has and what it convers, etc, but EVRYONE certainly knows that by now.
 

I have a friend who went to one of those 9 month long "shake and bake" dog traing courses and learned everything from basic obedience to advanced protection where she can supposedly train a law enforcement K9.  Her "hands on" training was at the local vet office and animal rescue without supervision.  But she has that piece of paper that states she is certified.

Please tell me you understand how this is different from what I described already, a dozen times over.  If not, I'm not sure how much more descriptive I need to be at this point because what you are talking about here, is not, in any way, shape or form, what I've been talking about.

gsdpartisan

by gsdpartisan on 23 January 2014 - 19:01

Fawn,
If you have some time on your hands, read Steven Lindsay books Handbook of Applied Dog Behavior and Training Volumes 1, 2 & 3.

Follow the link to take a look at the books:   Steven Lindsay Books

Many behaviorists use only "all positive" methods which is unrealistic and with the wrong dogs can be dangerous.  If you want information about dogs--what they are thinking, how to train them with both positive and negative methods (even the use of e-collar), how to deal with aggression, separation anxiety, crate training, dominance..anything you can think of--these are the books for you.  The books are sometimes hard to understand and some of the neurobiology, cerebral cortex, neurotransmitters etc stuff you can skip, but the books are imo, priceless

Start with Volume 1--Classical Conditioning and Instrumental Learning.  The books are really fascinating.

momosgarage

by momosgarage on 23 January 2014 - 19:01

Good call gsdpartisan, I had to use these book in school.

Two Moons

by Two Moons on 23 January 2014 - 20:01

Kinolog,
LOL.... you have nothing better to do, googling and taking pills?


Momo,
Than have your electrian stamp and sign the drawings for plan review at the city, the next time you need a permit for a home renovation.  As I'm sure you realize, your son, if he chooses, can take that license exam one day, if he passes, he could then stamp those drawings and get a permit.  Your eletrician cannot do that legally and if the calculations are complicated and not reviewed by an engineer, he puts you at physcial risk.  Your electrician may not mention that part, to you, where he has a Licensed Professional Engineer in the State doing that work for him, but it was possbily bundled into the fee you paid him.

It depends on where your at.
I do residential electrical wiring new and repair, I only have to follow established codes and hold no license.
I do plumbing, same story.
I do have to pass inspections, but I do such a good job that's no problem at all.
Not only do I build but I design some of what I build, make the blue prints and figure materials to the last nail, and where i'm at now i hold no license for that either.

I agree with your post but just like before it's not universal, you should get out more, visit other cities, some places all it takes is money, pay the right person and you can just about do anything.
i've seen this activity in several major cities.

 

by gsdstudent on 24 January 2014 - 09:01

here in the great tundra sometime known as the eastern USA, we do not need a chill pill, at the moment l!!! I am glad my silly attempt at humor was not taken out of context but seen as a prod to investigate further. Fawn D might be looking for advice on her own dogs. She has been given great insight  She needs to investigate for herself. I do believe the original question was a prompt for a quest. Have fun with your dogs! 

Hired Dog

by Hired Dog on 24 January 2014 - 10:01

Mindhunt, the E collar is the most complete training tool available, if you understand how to apply it correctly. A correction, via a choker or a prong or a flat collar or E collar, etc, does not feel good, otherwise whats the sense of issuing one. The myth that "all dogs want to please us" should have died by now, but, apparently it has not. If that were the case, food and toys, etc, would not be involved in any training as "payments" because the dogs would work just to make us happy.
There are indeed VERY few dogs around that are tractable enough to work simply for praise. I owned one of them once, I know and she was the best female GSD anyone could ask for.
As far as setting dogs up for failure, that depends on what you mean by that because I will test my dogs during proofing by offering all types of distractions to entice them to make a mistake so they can be corrected..some dogs will fall for the distraction, some wont and the rewards and corrections are handed out accordingly. As soon as everyone accepts that the only reason training works is because of consequences, both good and bad, the better off dogs will be. Fawn, sorry for derailing this thread for a minute.





 


Contact information  Disclaimer  Privacy Statement  Copyright Information  Terms of Service  Cookie policy  ↑ Back to top