Anyone feed Fromm? Too rich for GSD's? - Page 2

We feed Taste of the Wild to our german shepherds.  We use Fromm for our show chihuahuas and the protein content is only around 24 so should be fine for German Shepherds.

Fromm Gold  contains menedione .

    gouda

I love Victor, IMO the best dog food I've ever fed in 50+ years of dog ownership. Small, firm stools, a massive beautiful coat, perfect weight, clean teeth, great physical condition in my 7  year old female. I can't say enough about that brand. 

No it doesn't
 

http://frommfamily.com/products/gold/dog/dry/adult-gold/

I stopped feeding it last year because of it.

I live in Canada.  It was written wih  the ingredience on the bag itself.

Mayby they have taken it out now,dont know.

  gouda

http://itchmoforums.com/your-problems-with-pet-food/why-does-fromms-four-star-dry-dog-food-contain-menadione-t3510.0.html

I used to get it elivere in white 40lb. kennel bags.

I SEE THEY HAVE CHANGED,but have they changed the delivery bags for kenels that

are not sold in stores?

http://www.poltross.com/dogfood/adult_gold.htm

  gouda

Are you in th US?  Because it doesn't contain it in my bags

What should be the ideal percentage of protein and fat in dog food for German Shepherd? I see many 4 or 5 stars dog foods are with >30% protein and some even pushing to 40%. However, I have heard some said that the protein level should not be so high for GSD. Is that correct and why?

That Fromm talk is B.S. Gouda, quoting another forum as evidence is not really very  scientific. 

In 2006 or 2008 all menadione was removed from any Fromm formulas. Regardless, small doses of menadione are not a concern like large doses are. Again, it pays to really understand a controversy before deciding which side you're on and CERTAINLY before bashing a company!