what happened to the real german shepherds? - Page 4

So what Steve1 is saying is that if someone jumps at him they will get beat up? I guess if he is holding a gun then someone jumps at him but never touches him then they deserve to get shot? Is that what you are saying? LOL

You people's egos are out of control and evidently extremely fragile ha ha!

I stand by what I said. The dog or handler was never touched or assuated then there should be no bite. 

i agree with steve already being a victim of violent crime he doesnt shouldnt have to" wait to be beaten or hit for him or his dog to defend him all it takes is a threatening move forward and any jackass would deserve to get hit or bit JMho i dont know what the law will say though


same goes for a women thats about to be molested shes not gonna wait till shes being raped to defend herself soon as a guy makes a threatening move towards her she or her dog should have the right to dispatch that man any way possible but again i dont know what the law says on that depends on the area

For the OP he says it was his friends dog and i guess they knew he was doing it, or maybe they were training who knows he doesnt seem like he falls into this catagory


now if someone by mistake jmps at your dog or you in excitment because they wanna pet or kiss it or something yeah they are stupid but no they dont deserve to be hit


a lot of confusion going on around here


JUMPINg at a dog can mean many things a person can do it cause they are excited and happy to see a cute dog or someone can do it in a threatening manner you can easily tell the diff


at the start people had the impression the OP was going around a club and sneaking up on people and their dogs and jumping at them which we now know is not the case lol

SMITH I sent you a text btw :P

"this site is a joke!"

So, let me get this straight...a couple of years ago, you show up here asking whether your dog's pedigree is any good and now you're suddenly an expert qualified to critique other people's dogs? 

judy i thought u had a real nice serious gsd also

We are talking about someone jumping at a dog at a club not a real threat. Of course if you feel threatened for your life by all means defend. This is an idiot jumping at a dog just to see what it is going to do not a rapist.....well LOL hopefully not LMAO! I still say the idiot does not deserve to get bit or beat up for simply being an idiot.

keith ive never gave a opinion to anyone about their dog.  you must be really bored to do a background check on my post! get a life creep

Smith
I was refering to anyone who jumped on me and my Dog not you in particular, However If the cap fits then where it.
 The way i took the OP was jumping on the Dog and Handler and being a complete stranger to them , Who else on here would not react the way i would certainly if you were watching other handlers and there dogs working and probably with your back to the one jumping on you

I had that in a main street once when i was younger, a work mate came through the crowd bobbing and weaving towards me coming the opposite way, i did not recognize him at that moment in among the people thinking it was a nutter,
Well he was flattened out on the pavement very quickly. then i saw who it was, A stupid thing for him to do but i react purely on reflexes and instinct that is built into me nothing can change that nor do i want to, i will of course talk afterwards if needs be

Sportyguy
If someone jumps you what do you say to them do not do that i do not like it and try and reason with them,
Like Hell how do you know what there intent is, you deal with it first then look to see who it is
Those two Thugs in the UK what would you have done let them knock you about and rob you or Fight, No chance i will give way to anyone in that situation if i am going to be put out i will not give up that easy, nothing big about it just survival.
 Too many give way to thugs and still end up in hospital or dead, Better fight and go out in the right way if that is to happen not give way like a frightened cowering person, That just cannot happen
Oh' and i am just an ordinary person who gets on well with people in real life and would not normally say BOO to a Goose so to speak, but threatened in anyway i change completely as do most people
Steve1

To the OP and sporty :

 IF you were at  any club that I have ever trained at and you did make a jump at a dog you might get bit but you would defiantly get your ass handed to you by the handler and told to leave the club and not welcomed back.

It,s this mentality that makes it hard for all the people who work and train there dog,s to be taken seriously when you have people who think "Hey watch this" mentality.


Jumping at a dog in most cases is a threat or at least a challenge to them so a reaction will occur depending on the training or experience of the dog will be the qualifing issue. I,m intrested to know what the OP feels would of been the proper response for a REAL (theres that word again)dog to have done? Should it of ripped you to the bone? bark agressivley? stand it,s ground quietly and wait for a scarrier jump?.

smith or sporty I sure would like to see some of your dogs worked and see your idea of a real dog training. Do you have any video of said dogs and the work they do? would you be available to give a example with your dogs on the proper response that should be expected?.

 I don,t expect my dogs to protect me I do that for my self but I do expect them to react as a dog does and with the training accordingly they have experienced.




   

Not any dog in particular, Smith, but you sure are talking a lot of smack for someone with an untitled dog out of a mixture of untitled show and working lines who you've taken it upon yourself to breed, twice, apparently before she was even two years old.  I find the OFA good rating you've entered for her suspect as well since I can't find any mention of her in the OFA database.

And yes, I like to know to whom I'm talking before I give any consideration to his/her opinions.

Here's a good rule: Don't ever do anything to a strange dog that you wouldn't do to a stranger. And I agree with Bob. That would be the last we would see of you. I would only accept that from a mentally ill or slow person. Even kids that come to the club are better behaved.